7.28.2009

It used to be better, so let's make it even less like it used to be

Nurse Ratched is, well, a nurse, and she is in support of a public option for health care. I think her point about rationing care is right on. We already do it, from not going to the doctor every time we cough, to GPs not pushing for a specialist consults when they are unlikely to turn up anything, to insurance companies not covering highly experimental procedures. The difference is that insurance companies ration payment while government would ration procedures. They are not the same thing, but that leads to my next point:

Everyone is in a rancor about the cost of health care, but I don't think that cost is the primary sticking point. If you told me that I could live to 200, but that I would have to spend 50% of my income to do it, I would find a cheap apartment and start eating Ramen every night. Wait, I do that already. But you get the point. People by and large are willing to pay for good health, and a dying man will clutch anything but his checkbook. The problem with the current system is uncertainty, because health insurance is not health insurance. Insurers will try to reject anything they can, and in the end you put in hundreds of hours for them to cover some percentage of your costs that is well below 100%.

She blames fat cat CEOs and shareholders, the usual suspects and everyone's favorite targets. She says that if they weren't taking home big salaries and profits this wouldn't be a problem. This is mostly true. But while she establishes the correct arguments, Nurse Ratched whiffs the conclusion. It is the same fallacy I pointed out in Malcolm Gladwell's piece a while back. She even points out the fatal flaw in her argument for us in her opening stanza:
I remember when nurses and insurance companies use to get along with each other. Back in the 1960s, these nurses even took time out of their busy schedules to pose for one of their ads. We took care of patients at the bedside, and the insurance companies paid the hospital bill. It was as simple as that, but then things started to change. It began with three little letters—HMO
The problem isn't private insurance, in other words, it was whatever happened that brought about HMOs. I contend that this was dense thickets of regulations. These made compliance too expensive for small, traditional insurers. They also put up roadblocks - literally - so that private groups could not deduct their insurance costs, and in fact could not even legally set up joint funds for medical costs. We have been steadily erecting barriers to entry and cutting down grassroots competition for nearly 50 years in medicine. If we had done the same thing in, say, education, imagine what the consequences would have been. Oh, wait. Nevermind.

The other thing the good nurse says is that we need a public option. She again preempts herself by noting that, uh, we do have a public option. We have several of them. They are called Medicare, Medicaid, SCHIP, and higher bills to cover free care for those who cannot afford insurance. Actually, it turns out that we all subsidize Medicare through the back door because they get to dictate rates rather than pay what is charged. So really, there is a huge amount of subsidy already in the system. Why does everyone think that a little bit more will dramatically lower costs?

In summary, I only see one problem with the current system, and that is the lack of ethics in actually paying out insurance policies. I don't think cost is a problem per se. I do think vastly greater competition would vastly improve the system, and unlike socialized medicine proponents I can point to an existence proof of a system in America that worked this way and worked well, nostalgia notwithstanding. You don't bring back the good old days by running away.


7.12.2009

Recovery?

Robert Reich has an interesting theory about this recession: it will not have a recovery. At least, that's the title, but he hedges by saying the economy will "change" at the end, which is a bit like saying that if I eat, food will not come out of my body. The commenters fall over themselves to congratulate the great insight, as though the guy just invented something called creative destruction or something. More evidence of general economic illiteracy, but I'm not going to complain about that here.

So how DO we come out of this? A few of the lackiest writers out there have been trying to compare this recession to the last one, but that is foolish. It is much closer to the last two big ones: 1980-83 (I'll count it as one despite some recovery between, because the second dip was deeper than the first) and the GD (ditto). There is no long wave issue here - the economy is a chaotic system, and at best any long-term rhythm is just a strange attractor. What is at issue is that the economy is phase shifting, always a dangerous and giddy time to say the least. Once FDR finally and thankfully got the fuck out of its way, the economy changed from agriculture-and-mass-production to the mega-industrial complex of the 50's and 60's. After this house came down through the 70's and early 80's, we got service and high-tech. Now? Here are some possibilities I can see:

1. The market does what socialists keep trying to get the government to do, and evens out income disparity. I'm not talking so much about disparity within the US. I am talking about first world vs. third world. Already China is bouncing a lot sooner out of its funk. It spent the last two decades running against time to build enough breathing room into its economy and those around it that it could take advantage of a time like this. India is in worse straits, but still better off than us and Europe. Face it. With globalization, we were never going to keep up 10-to-1 income disparities with our suppliers. We had a good ride while it lasted. The hope here is that living standards slow or stagnate, rather than falling off a cliff. Eventually, the majority of the world will be making $30,000 a year, and then (probably well before then) the manufacturing and industry jobs will come back. It's not a bad thing. I am willing to give up 1000 sq ft of house if it will raise 5 billion people out of subsistence. The innovative power alone of having all those people free from the plow and able to afford an education is enough to probably change the human race into something we can't imagine in a shockingly short time.

What can the US possibly offer during this period that might pay for the wait for everyone to catch up? In the business world, those who don't physically produce but still make a lot of money are either lawyers, financiers, or consultants. The first option seems to be cornered by Europe, who comes up with a new layer of bureaucracy and governance every other week. The second option seems to be the one we're pursuing, just because we were the first and most aggressive at opening up our financial markets, and because we, uh, print all the gold. But money is so fluid in the days of ubiquitous computing that we will be hard-pressed to maintain that middleman role much longer. The dollar is quickly becoming the world's largest toxic asset, and the US people will be the shareholders in the bank that is holding them. Also, we're bad at it.

I like the third option. We can become the Athens of the modern world. We are currently on a trajectory to absolutely roast this goose. Throwing government cash at more and more federal laboratories might make for interesting journal articles, but doing that will not make us money.it will make us the PhD students of the world: smart, sheltered, and... dirt poor. If we want to stay the world's foremost incubator of marketable ideas, we need to de-regulate venture capital markets, de-regulate and de-tax small businesses, and perhaps above all make immigration easier for smart people. The best idea I have heard is to automatically issue a green card to anyone with a bachelor's degree. I would extend this to anyone with a letter of admission to a US university (take away the slave labor and ridiculous restrictions, let them work like citizens), and anyone who has been granted a patent or anyone in an executive or board position at a profitable business. We need to be an idea factory, unless we are ready to compete on a wage basis with Sumatrans.

2. Jobs will come out of some emerging industry sector. This is arguably what happened in the last two decades with the information revolution. The US economy keeps pulling rabbits out of the hat. There is no reason it cannot do so again. Certain prognosticators like Aubrey de Grey and Ray Kurzweil believe that biotechnology - and I'm saying that broadly, to include things like human-AI interfaces and genetically engineered crops - is ready to be the Next Big Thing. I don't know how well it can penetrate the US medical-industrial complex, but it's possible. I won't try to prognosticate this. Even the very most optimistic investors in the thick of the recession in 1982 would not have expected a couple shares of Apple to fund his retirement. It didn't become apparent what was going on until the early '90s and the internet. As I heard Burt Rutan say once, we were buying computers for 20 years before we figured out what the damn things are for.

3. Inflate. This will kill the dollar standard, which on the whole would have to be seen as a good thing. Nations are just jockeying for who gets to tank the dollar at this point. We are way over-exposed by being the world's reserve currency. For all the power we think it gives us, we can bit back just as badly in monetary terms, and much worse in real terms because we have to use the stuff to buy food.

The problem becomes, if we inflate the dollar we risk destroying a lot of other economies who were foolish enough to invest in us on the downside. If you thought the '08 credit crisis was bad, imagine if it was nations going bankrupt. International trade would collapse, and it would be a miracle if a world war didn't ensue. This is if we totally devalue the stuff. If we balance our budget and slowly inflate over the course of ten years, then the world will do okay. The transfer to a free market of currencies will be a gradual, nation-by-nation affair. There will be some binational disputes over payments, but nothing will blow up. We will be poorer in real terms at the end. But it's a very tight rope to walk.

4. War. A world war. These tend not to solve things, but they do force reality on most of the big players. They destroy a huge amount of wealth, and knock the battlefield inhabitants back generations in terms of living standards. And this time there won't be an undamaged superpower like in 1945 to fund the whole cleanup. This would be a terrible thing in every way.


7.11.2009

Meet the new boss, part what, seven?

Obama was against presidential signing statements in the campaign. But now he's for them! And he even has a reason! Paging Dr. Orwell. Dr. Orwell please...

7.10.2009

Figures

I am writing my thesis right now, trying to conform to the rules in "Engineered Writing" by Melba Jerry Murray. It's an excellent book my boss gave me at the company I'm doing my research at. One of the best suggestions is to make your figures first, and then do the writing around them.

Now, I could write at length about California's budget seppuku. I could even make it funny and interesting to read. But I would rather just show the picture:


6.27.2009

Waxman-Markey debate

In this weeks version of fun in politics, Rep. Jim Boehner R-OH, the House Minority Leader, took the stand today and started reading the 300-page amendment that was tacked onto Waxman-Markey at the last minute. Literally. Reading the thing.

Searching for an apt metaphor to what the Democrats have been doing procedurally since sweeping the trifecta... here it is: They're like a serial rapist who gets off on a technicality, then the first thing he does is go to a schoolyard with class in session, pull down his pants, and start shaking hands vigorously with Mr. Marbles. It's going to end badly for them. I just don't get it.

6.24.2009

Dear Barack, or: How to make your presidency not a complete disaster

I like Barack Obama about as much as I liked the George Bushes or Clinton... okay, I liked Clinton a little more, but only because he had a deadlocked congress to not do his bidding. Now that I'm getting over the shock of the fiscal insanity that is going on, and reserved to watching the dollar lose 3/4 of its value in the next 10 years, I'm trying to find subtle sparkles to the touches of grey. I'm thinking there are a few things that might go the right way with this administration, if they have any of the balls or vision they keep telling us they have. So here goes:

#1: End or significant softening of the War on Drugs. The WoD has been an abject failure - it has not changed the proportion of people who do drugs, it has made the drugs that are on the streets less safe, it has created a huge mafia-run black market, it has made us into hypocrites and bullies on the world stage, and it has created millions of lifetime criminals by locking up non-violent offenders. 25% of the world's prisoners are in American jails, and we have the gall to talk about China's political prisoners. It won't be a sweeping dismantling of the DEA, but I can see these steps being taken:
  • A bill that passes jurisdiction over to the states for marijuana (or better, all drug) control.
  • A bill that eliminates mandatory minimum sentences for non-violent drug offenses
  • A tax on legal drug transactions - I don't like taxes, but making something into a source of revenue is a sure way to make sure it doesn't become a source of prisoners
#2: Pull the military back onto American shores. Obama seems keen to target military spending. I think that's the last thing you should target, but there is good military spending and there is bad military spending. American might is all about kill ratios: you might kill our guys and gals, but they'll take out 40 of your before you do. It is based on technology, logistical superiority, and the ability to communicate the field of battle before your enemy can. In this context, maintaining an umbrella of bases and a standing army in Europe, and securing their oil supply with the same in the Middle East, makes no sense. Asia too. The world is a tinderbox; but right now we are standing with an ever-weakening garden sprinkler trying to keep it from combusting. We need the equivalent of a good pair of binoculars and a bucket of sand. We'd be better off with a force based on "shock and awe" rapid response than one based on blanketing. This transition was started by Bush Sr., and I hope Obama cuts in the right places.

#3: Bring back civil liberties. I have seen no sign that Obama intends to do this, unfortunately. If anything, he will retain the massive executive powers that Bush Jr. gathered and "choose" not to use them - a situation that the founders would have called insane. I guess we see the Dems' true colors now - with them in power, where is all the outcry about rolling back the PATRIOT Act? Where is the urgency to extract ourselves from Iraq (and now we're going into Mexico...) Of all his broken campaign promises, this is the one that will destroy him.

#4: Stop minority victimhood. If nothing else, and I think I see it around me even now, I hope that having a black president removes the cult of victimhood that is a blight on minority, and especially American Black, communities. We can all grow up to be president now, so hopefully everyone can stop complaining about their societally-imposed disadvantages and use them as a motivating tool. Like, you know, every immigrant group that has ever come into this country.

6.23.2009

How to supercharge the economy

The Futurist had a brilliant piece on 8 ways to supercharge the US economy. Most are common sense and reasonably un-partisan. Here they are:

6 for Government:
1) Allow anyone with a bachelor's degree to work in the US, no questions asked. My wife and I are currently going through the process of getting her a green card. It is unconscionable. We have had the smoothest possible route and used no lawyers, and it will cost us about $3000 and a year apart when all is said and done. She has a bachelor's degree from a US university, and has worked in the US before. I would say, just throw open the borders period; but I can see where that would go politically. But seriously, we lose the productivity of a class of people (educated immigrants) who start businesses and employ people and innovate at way, way, way above the national average. Then we turn around and lose outsourced jobs because those same people are starting companies in their home countries. We lose an average of probably 3-4 jobs (real jobs, not the kind that the government "makes") for every college-educated immigrant we keep out of the US. It's beyond stupid.

2) Simplify the tax code. How about just getting rid of it altogether? If that's not going to happen, there are a half dozen better way than an intrusive and loophole-filled income tax. A national sales tax would be fair and it would promote savings and investment over consumption. A property tax, especially an unimproved value tax rather than an assessed value tax, would be about as fair as you can get - tax people for the value they don't create, only sit on and scarcify. Or a resource extraction/destruction tax that taxed corporations or individuals for withdrawing natural resources or polluting. The point is, there is not a worse way to do it than we are doing it.

3) Exempt entrepreneurs from taxes on their shares and options. I love this one, but I wonder what you would call an "entrepreneur" - is it an initial shareholder? That seems reasonable, but then you would have rich people incorporating zombie companies for the tax shelter. I like the idea of a 0% corporate tax on revenues only for the first 3 years of incorporation. But it's all a little contrived. Really, if you want to make entrepreneurship live again in the US, you would do some simple things: massive deregulation of markets, massive deregulation of private investment, make health care a personal expense again, cut the corporate and personal income tax rates.

4) Make Sarbanes-Oxley voluntary. Along with just about every accounting law or regulation on the books for businesses.

5) Reform divorce laws. He argues that easy assymetrical alimony + no-questions divorce = lots of divorced men with little financial incentive to work hard. True. How about this: reform marriage law. As in, get rid of it. Why does the government have ANY business in the institution of marriage? Seriously! Why?

6) Make tax day one day before election day. This is ingenious. This alone would go a long way towards making us hold our politicians responsible. But I would suggest pairing this with an end to paycheck exemptions, so that everyone had to write a humongous check the day before election day.

For corporations:
7) Try salary reductions before you go for layoffs. I don't see why this isn't done more. You could even offer stock to people who get their pay axed, as an incentive to help pull the company through. Layoffs and re-hiring are a phenomenal expense and inefficiency.

For the people:
8) Improve your health through easy stuff. Change your diet and exercise. Save us hundreds of billions per year, and live happier and longer lives. All it takes is some discipline. Indeed.

It's a pretty good list. Most of these suggestions are in the "duh." column. Unfortunately, they're pretty unlikely to happen.

6.21.2009

Meet the new boss, part... uh, what number are we up to now?

Obama likes to hide political treats in his continuing resolutions for the war in Iraq too... including... wait for it... war in Mexico!

http://reason.com/blog/show/134228.html

6.17.2009

Meet the new boss, part 6

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/31373407/ns/politics-white_house/

I have nothing to add here, except that the opaqueness has shifted from Abu Ghraib to the New York Fed. It's moving closer to home!

6.09.2009

Atlas Shrugged: Casting

Heretical Ideas had a segment on the perfect Atlas Shrugged movie. I agree, it would have to be a trilogy to do it right. I thought I'd try my hand at casting:

Leo DiCaprio would be my pick for d'Anconia. He has that manic streak, but also the penetrating good looks and intelligence. Jude Law or Robert Downey Jr. might also pull it off. If you need to go lower budget, Owen Wilson might be your man. Daniel Day Lewis would be my Hank Rearden - he played Sinclair's version of the magnate so well in There Will Be Blood - I think he captured the goodness very well before he turned evil in that movie. Donnie Wahlberg would be good if you wanted to go young. Russell Crowe could do this role also, but not as well as Lewis. Dagny Taggart- Kate Blanchett is perfect, as would be Kate Winslet. I can also see Scarlett Johannson, Natalie Portman, Julianne Moore, Claire Danes, Gwyneth Paltrow, Rachel McAdams, and a number of other actresses pulling the role off. The role is basically the classical strong women with a soft side... she has to balance a strong personality with the ability to get hurt, and to top it all off she has to convincingly fall in love with three men. Word on the street is that it is Angelina Jolie - she's a little soft; I think she'd be better as Lily Rearden. Hugh Akston - Morgan Freeman is the obvious choice from the philosopher perspective. George Takei could do the philosopher part, although he may be too old to realistically run a diner. Ian McKellan and Patrick Stewart could do it too. I think these choices overplay the philosopher and maybe underplay the diner cook; Robert Redford and Clint Eastwood would be up there with Freeman, but Freeman takes it by a nose. You could also go way out there with this one and cameo Tarantino or something; it's really wide open. Jim Taggart - Crowe is not sleezy and desperate enough. He would play it too "cool" - As I mentioned earlier, I could actually see him as Hank Rearden before I could see him as Jim Taggart. It's a challenging role - he has to have a boastfulness when things are going his way, and a whiny blamefulness when things are not. Maybe Obama could fit it in his schedule? But I digress. I think Ben Affleck could pull this off, or maybe even Keanu Reeves (!) - lots of style, little substance, and a short memory. Jim Carrey could probably do it too - he's shown the ability to play dark comedy - but my thought is he would be too intelligent for the role. This is a tough one. I'll have to come back to it.

UPDATE: I think the Jim Taggart role would suit Joaquin Phoenix. He basically played it in Gladiator. My friend just suggested Alan Rickman - I like that even better.

Cherryl Brooks - Christina Ricci or Kirsten Dunst have the ability to play the helpless but good-hearted girl next door, although the role might be too small for them. Joey Lauren Adams could work.

Cuffy Meigs - the brutish military officer, the Gestapo enforcer who bides his time until he is the only one who can "save" the government. Can't just be a Luco Brazzi type guy - he also has a head on his shoulders. Christopher Walken? Cillian Murphy? Benicio del Toro (too small a role)? Forest Whitaker was great as Idi Amin, and having a facial scar or a bum eye helps the role significantly. Dennis Quaid might work. But I would go with one of the Platoon sargents - Tom Berenger or Willem Dafoe. I don't remember the character from the book very well, so I'm going on archetype here.
Dan Conway - the cowboy businessman; a genius who dresses and talks like an everyman. He should be a well-built man, but soft-spoken. It's a small role, so it might not even be in the movie - but it's an important conversation because it shows one alternative to the organized strike. Tommy Lee Jones would be great in this cameo. Tom Sizemore too. If I could choose one person though, it would have to be Chris Cooper.

Eddie Willers - where do you find an actor who will play an unexceptional intellect? That's tough. You don't want to go with an unexceptional actor for such a pivotal role, so humility is the number one trait you're looking for. Don Cheadle is a guy who can play humility, as could Tom Hanks. I think Liam Neeson could do it, also Tom Sizemore. Philip Seymour Hoffman could do it for sure. Tough one. I've also always thought Willers should be a funny guy, and although it's not really there in the book I could imagine a guy like Bill Murray, Will Ferrell, or Ricky Gervais playing a truly memorable Eddie Willers.

John Galt - I don't see the problem with this casting. Most actors seem to think of themselves as Galt - the Great Man in every way. A lot of older guys from the Golden Age had the swagger to pull it off - Eastwood, Redford, Beatty, Brando, pre-collapse Mel Gibson, and DeNiro come to mind. I think they are too old for the role though. I agree Denzel Washington would be a great choice for the role. Brad Pitt, Leo DiCaprio (better as d'Anconia, but he could do Galt too), Matt Damon, Jamie Foxx, Will Smith, and Tom Cruise are viable choices. I could see Christian Bale in a pinch, but not really.

Lillian Rearden - frigid, cheating, emasculating, uses sex as a bargaining tool. All the negative traits of woman in an outwardly beautiful package. The linked post says Lucy Liu, and I have no objections. Angelina Jolie could do it with a hand tied behind her back, but it's too small a role to pay for her. Keira Knightley would do it to death, and I mean that in a bad way. Jessica Alba is that person in real life, but she's not all that great an actor for what you pay for. Nicole Kidman obviously, Halle Berry, Mila Kunis, Ziyi Zhang, Michele Pfeiffer, Mena Suvari, Marisa Tomei... this one's too easy.

Midas Mulligan - I always pictured him as portly and bald. Drew Carey would be great for this role. John Goodman might pull it off too.

Wesley Mouch - Kevin Spacey could play the sleezy spineless lobbyist, but I think he's too intelligent. Jason Schwartzman has that overwhelmed look to him. The problem is that you need to find a guy who can be dark, but also not terribly intelligent. Ed Norton could do this one too, and I think Jeremy Piven would be a worthy backup.

Orren Boyle - David Huddleston or Gene Hackman

Robert Stadler - the linked site suggest Robert Duvall. I could see him being apolitical, and I can see him acting blinded to what is going on. So I'm for that one. Let me also put Philip Seymour Hoffman's name in the running on this one.

Philip Rearden - Seth Green or Simon Pegg.

Rearden's Mother - She does charity work, and comes across as holier-than-thou. I can see Meryl Streep in this role. If you want to take it more holier, Goldie Hawn would work; more sarcastic and vicious, Christina Rose could do it.

Ragnar Danneskjold - Djimon Hounsou, Colin Farrell, Jude Law, Robert Downey Jr. And hey, he's a pirate, so why not Johnny Depp?

The looters circle would have to work well. Let's say we already have Joaquin Phoenix as Jim Taggart, and Ed Norton as Mouch. Tom Berenger is Meigs, kind of on the outer edges of the circle. Simon Pritchett is the hack academic sophist philosopher, a sort of Trotsky type whom everyone gets sick of listening to. Alec Baldwin works in that role, few can look serious ripping off a ridiculous monologue like he can, but Patrick Stewart could be good if he could tone down the intellect. Dr. Floyd Ferris, the cunning underling who manipulates Stadler and takes credit for Project X, could be played by Giovanni Ribisi (hard to beat for evil looks), Zachary Quinto, or Steve Buscemi? And for the headless president Mr. Thompson, the master of backroom deals and politics, Jack Nicholson or Sam Jackson would work. Balph Eubanks is the pompous writer; I picture someone slightly flamboyant like maybe a highly restrained Nathan Lane or Christopher Lee or James Woods.

Ken Dannager - Mickey Rourke or Edward James Olmos or Kurt Russell

Ben Nealy - Orlando Bloom, Ben Affleck, James Spader

Well, there you go. Let's see if I hit any of them as information comes out.


6.03.2009

Cars, cars, cars

In the wake of GM and Chrysler bailouts and bankruptcies, I have absorbed a lot of information about the US auto industry.  It is interesting to see some of the scapegoats.  Here are a few things I've heard that sounded reasonable but turned out to be ridiculous:

GM & Chrysler are mismanaged.  It is more honest to say the were mismanaged, a long time ago, in the 1960's.  This was back when the car companies employed far, far more workers than today, and when the industry was in a post-war growth spurt.  Rather than disburse the earnings to the workers then, the companies decided to play the ol' Social Security slight of hand and just promise them money later.  Unfortunately for everyone involved (except the executives, whose families continue to be rich), the industry became more productive faster than the market became bigger.  From a high of somewhere in the range of 400,000-600,000 workers, GM's payroll dropped to less than 100,000 today.  They don't make fewer cars - it's just that, due to better design and production processes, automation, and other advances, they are able to make them with fewer people.  Unfortunately, all their legacy pension costs are still there; so every current GM employee must work hard enough for himself and a retiree somewhere.  Some would look at this and say, well, those pensions should have been socialized - which just bumps the risk up a level or two.  Or, that those executives in the 60's should have foreseen the massive productivity leaps and planned for it better.  But that's a little bit ridiculous.  The real problem was those executives writing IOUs rather than giving the money straight up to their workers in individual retirement accounts of some sort.  Pension, both public and private, are generally sunk by wishful thinking.

Detroit makes cars nobody wants to drive.  Pshaw.  Detroit still has a huge market share, and GM is the second-largest car company in the world.  For every Pinto there has been a dozen Corvettes, Mustangs, Caravans, Tauruses, Neons, Saturns, and other popular, quality cars.  Mechanics I have spoken to will vouch that there is little quality difference between the cars that come out of Detroit and those of other countries, dollar for dollar.

Detroit has been derailed by a sick SUV fetish.  Somewhat true - but only in terms of the lobbyists employed by the companies (at great expense) to get laws passed for tax breaks and emissions standards that favored large SUVs, trucks, and vans.  People wanted SUVs because gas was cheap; if the companies had been forced to respond to the market they would have done so.  Instead, they trusted their lobbying bubble too long despite oil price signals to the contrary.  Detroit was not the only ones pushing the tank version of the family car, but if anything it covered up the extreme and perverse financial situation with pensions for a few years longer, and instead of failing in good times when laid off workers could find work elsewhere, they failed in bad times (as per usual when government tries to legislate away economic ills, it just makes them worse).  SUVs didn't kill the big three.

So what now?  I'm a little flustered with the mass infusions of cash down the hole, and a little more so with the huge equity stakes the government took.  If you want to give the cash to get them through bankruptcy, then do so.  I get it.  You can't have people getting laid off into this economy, and I can see the advantages there.  But attaching strings of equity is silly - you have to divest at some point, and then how is it different from simply having given a loan?  Either way, you'll be starving the company of cash flow at some point - one from flooding the market with their equity, and the other from loan payments.  In the case of a loan, at least they can plan the payments.

5.24.2009

Dependency Ratios for Companies and Countries

I've been devouring Malcolm Gladwell's slate of New Yorker columns the last couple days.  I especially enjoy the way he looks at common problems in a unique light.  For instance, in regards to national growth spurts and corporate pensions he highlights the importance of the dependency ratio, which is the ratio of dependent members of a group to productive members: 

Demographers estimate that declines in dependency ratios are responsible for about a third of the East Asian economic miracle of the postwar era; this is a part of the world that, in the course of twenty-five years, saw its dependency ratio decline thirty-five per cent. Dependency ratios may also help answer the much-debated question of whether India or China has a brighter economic future. Right now, China is in the midst of what Joseph Chamie, the former director of the United Nations' population division, calls the "sweet spot." In the nineteen-sixties, China brought down its birth rate dramatically; those children are now grown up and in the workforce, and there is no similarly sized class of dependents behind them. India, on the other hand, reduced its birth rate much more slowly and has yet to hit the sweet spot. Its best years are ahead.

Gladwell rightly notes that the concept of company-funded pensions and health care is a dead-end street.  If the company becomes more productive, it lays off workers and creates unproductive obligations.  Since it must continue becoming productive, the only reasonable solution is endless growth - which is not possible in the scheme of decades and generations.  Hence, he says, we have perverse market incentives like GM selling cars at a loss in order to keep from laying off its workforce.

Gladwell's proposed solution is government pensions and health care: 

If you combined the obligations of G.M., with its four hundred and fifty-three thousand retirees, and the American manufacturing operations of Toyota, with a mere two hundred and fifty-eight retirees, Toyota could help G.M. shoulder its burden, and thirty or forty years from now—when those G.M. retirees are dead and Toyota's now youthful workforce has turned gray—G.M. could return the favor. For that matter, if you pooled the obligations of every employer in the country, no company would go bankrupt just because it happened to employ older people, or it happened to have been around for a while, or it happened to have made the transformation from open-hearth furnaces and ingot-making to basic oxygen furnaces and continuous casting.

I find this conclusion strange in a couple of ways, considering the evidence to the contrary in Gladwell's piece.  The first is his several-paragraph explanation of the deleterious effects that high dependency ratios have on not only businesses, but nations as well.  We see every year or so one or two countries go bankrupt or hyperinflate their currency.  Right now it's Zimbabwe and Iceland.  It happens with empires too - in fact, it's pretty difficult to bring an empire down in any way except economic collapse.  The argument that we would all be safer by concentrating risk with one payer rather than each company paying is ridiculous - the bankruptcies might be separated by centuries rather than decades, but the effects are so much worse that it's difficult to even compare the two with a straight face.  One notes that this doesn't happen to nearly the same degree with small corporations; why would making the pool larger make us all better off?

The second piece of evidence comes from Gladwell's open offering of, yet complete ignorance of the other, better answer: 

When Bethlehem Steel filed for bankruptcy, it owed about four billion dollars to its pension plan, and had another three billion dollars in unmet health-care obligations. Two years later, in 2003, the pension fund was terminated and handed over to the federal government's Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. The assets of the company—Sparrows Point and a handful of other steel mills in the Midwest—were sold to the New York-based investor Wilbur Ross.

Ross acted quickly. He set up a small trust fund to help defray Bethlehem's unmet retiree health-care costs, cut a deal with the union to streamline work rules, put in place a new 401(k) savings plan—and then started over. The new Bethlehem Steel had a dependency ratio of 0 to 1. Within about six months, it was profitable.

So the answer here was not spreading the risk among companies, per se - although that was the effect, since workers basically diversified the risk of Bethelem Steel going bankrupt by buying stocks and bonds in a wide range of companies and governments.  It was the opposite - mass-individualization.  The key is to put workers in control of their own retirement and health care costs through individual accounts.  The company now gives them cold, hard cash (with strings attached to be sure, but it's still their's) instead of IOUs.  They share profits during good times.  They take it with them when they leave, and when the company goes bankrupt.  Sounds pretty socialist to me.

The New Autopreneurs

A while back, I posted my thoughts on the economic disadvantages of keeping the Big 3 alive against all economic signals to the contrary.  The basic argument is that they are currently locking up a huge store of talent and resources in inefficient, bureaucratic, innovation-killing firms.  Set the smart people free.

Forbes has published a segment on America's new car companies.  They are pushing a range of models, mostly starting with luxury offerings in view of working their way down to the common man.  Take a look to see the kinds of companies your tax dollars are competing against.

5.21.2009

Meet the New Boss (5)

At Esquire, via Instapundit, it seems that this president doesn't really see too much wrong with the way the last president treated POUW's (prisoners of undeclared wars).  I'm really quite convinced they're all the same.
Beyond the rhetoric, then, Obama has told the world that America's definitions of terror remain its own. He says it's not a reversal? It is. The president has reminded the world of a Cheney-ism: We know terrorism when we see it, and when we see it, we'll let you know.

Bill of Federalism is here!

Geek that I am, I sometimes outline ideas for a Constitution that follows my beliefs about government.  Usually, I just end up tossing it away after a day or two because I quickly realize that no piece of paper, however self-consistent and respected by society, can truly arrest the creep of corporation and state power over the functions of force in society.  The people must do that, constantly and vigilantly.

Randy Barnett over at Forbes has drawn up a "Bill of Federalism," 10 proposed Constitutional amendments that he would like the states to convene to ratify.  Some thoughts:

Amendment 1: Limit the taxing powers of Congress to a flat sales tax.  I love it.  Economists are not unanimous about this, but in general it's a better idea to tax things at consumption rather than production - it increases savings (and therefore investment) and can really help to avoid the kind of debt hole we are currently letting our government dig us deeper into.  I would be very very careful about defining "uniform tax" and "sales" to prevent loopholing as much as possible.  The amendment also creates a necessity for a 60% vote of both houses for any tax or duty increase.  Again, this is just a great idea - although I would have started at 2/3rds and let the bastards negotiate it down.  This wouldn't work at all without Amendment 8 below though, and probably A3 as well.

A2: This amendment appears to be attempting to limit the uses and abuses of the Commerce Clause.  I am not really sure the wording here would do the job.  I think the Commerce Clause should be revoked in favor of a Commerce Court under the judiciary - so states can sue each other over, say, sulphur emissions floating downwind or contaminated produce being shipped in, but the Federal government cannot actively regulate.  Unfortunately, Eisenhower did a great disservice to the Commerce Clause by using it as an excuse to de-segregate the South... instead of having the chutzpah to just do it on humanitarian grounds.  Now its meaning is continually stretched to include intra-state commerce that might affect market prices and other ridiculousities; all without consent of the states being "protected."

A3:  This one seems to be aimed at getting rid of "strings attached" federal grants to states, but in reality it is aimed at significantly reducing federal grants to states.  This is a Good Thing - states that are financially dependent on the federal government are not federalist states.

A4:  Tries to stop the government from entering into treaties that enlarge the power of the government.  This amendment has no teeth in my opinion.  I don't see what is to stop the legislature from ratifying a treaty and simultaneously passing a bill that increases its powers or some-such.  If you want include a check on federal power, change the ratification process so that treaties must be ratified by 2/3rds of state legislatures.

A5:  Extends freedom of speech to campaign contributions.  It won't be popular among the Republicrat party heads, because campaign finance laws are how they make sure 3rd parties never get a foothold.  I like it nonetheless, and we might just have enough independent voters out there to make it real.

A6:  Grants state legislatures the ability to rescind federal law by a majority vote of 75%. The idea of states having direct power over national law is a good one.  However, it's almost unheard of for the states to form even a constitutional convention, never mind getting together to unseat a federal law.  If you want state review of federal laws, then it might be a better idea to make this the province of governors of states rather than legislatures.  The strength of the legislature approach is that governors are few and easy to corrupt, whereas even the most spendthrift congress probably can't get a check to every one of the thousands of state legislator and senators.  Or, why not go straight to the people with the California model?  We have the technology to put national iniatives on the ballot, why not make it a popular vote?  With no ability to create law, only to rescind it, I would support this.

A7:  Term limits for Congress (sky opens, choir of angels sings "Hallelujah")!  Our government is run by politicians and lawyers, not citizens.  This is bad for, pretty much, everyone except the politicians and lawyers.  Make the bastards find a real job, or at least change  jobs.

A8:  Balanced budget amendment.  The technical problem with a balanced budget amendment is that there is no way for the congress to know how much revenue will come in for a given year due to business cycles and other factors.   This amendment defines deficit, and gives the president a stick - a line-item veto for the next year.  This is self-defeatism dressed in the clothing of checks and balances.  If the president allows congress to run a deficit, he gets more power.  It essentially puts the power to balance the budget in the hands of the president, but not the incentive to do so.  I'm not sure what do to about this - perhaps the debt from one year should be constitutionally required to be an untouchable budget item for the next year.  Or, the president should be ineligible for re-election if his first term saw 2 or more years of deficits.

A9:  Section 1 is feel-goody libertarianese with little teeth.  Section 2 is a beautiful thing: it explicitly legalizes jury nullification.  This needs to happen.  I would be somewhat concerned that it would just lead to dumber juries; but adding a clause that juries must be informed of their powers granted by this amendment before trial would help.

A10:    It basically says that the constitution must be interpreted according to its meaning at enactment.  This is another toothless amendment, but it may be useful in decisions.  By which I mean, I could see this being totally ignored by most judges, but I can also see it being wielded as a catch-all argument for the strict constructionist side, kind of like an anti-commerce clause.  The Supreme Court pretty much acted according to this until about 1937, and since then it has been activist.  Codifying the conduct of federal judges probably won't help a whole lot, but it can't hurt.