6.21.2009
Meet the new boss, part... uh, what number are we up to now?
6.17.2009
Meet the new boss, part 6
6.09.2009
Atlas Shrugged: Casting
6.03.2009
Cars, cars, cars
5.24.2009
Dependency Ratios for Companies and Countries
I've been devouring Malcolm Gladwell's slate of New Yorker columns the last couple days. I especially enjoy the way he looks at common problems in a unique light. For instance, in regards to national growth spurts and corporate pensions he highlights the importance of the dependency ratio, which is the ratio of dependent members of a group to productive members:
Demographers estimate that declines in dependency ratios are responsible for about a third of the East Asian economic miracle of the postwar era; this is a part of the world that, in the course of twenty-five years, saw its dependency ratio decline thirty-five per cent. Dependency ratios may also help answer the much-debated question of whether India or China has a brighter economic future. Right now, China is in the midst of what Joseph Chamie, the former director of the United Nations' population division, calls the "sweet spot." In the nineteen-sixties, China brought down its birth rate dramatically; those children are now grown up and in the workforce, and there is no similarly sized class of dependents behind them. India, on the other hand, reduced its birth rate much more slowly and has yet to hit the sweet spot. Its best years are ahead.
Gladwell rightly notes that the concept of company-funded pensions and health care is a dead-end street. If the company becomes more productive, it lays off workers and creates unproductive obligations. Since it must continue becoming productive, the only reasonable solution is endless growth - which is not possible in the scheme of decades and generations. Hence, he says, we have perverse market incentives like GM selling cars at a loss in order to keep from laying off its workforce.
Gladwell's proposed solution is government pensions and health care:
If you combined the obligations of G.M., with its four hundred and fifty-three thousand retirees, and the American manufacturing operations of Toyota, with a mere two hundred and fifty-eight retirees, Toyota could help G.M. shoulder its burden, and thirty or forty years from now—when those G.M. retirees are dead and Toyota's now youthful workforce has turned gray—G.M. could return the favor. For that matter, if you pooled the obligations of every employer in the country, no company would go bankrupt just because it happened to employ older people, or it happened to have been around for a while, or it happened to have made the transformation from open-hearth furnaces and ingot-making to basic oxygen furnaces and continuous casting.
I find this conclusion strange in a couple of ways, considering the evidence to the contrary in Gladwell's piece. The first is his several-paragraph explanation of the deleterious effects that high dependency ratios have on not only businesses, but nations as well. We see every year or so one or two countries go bankrupt or hyperinflate their currency. Right now it's Zimbabwe and Iceland. It happens with empires too - in fact, it's pretty difficult to bring an empire down in any way except economic collapse. The argument that we would all be safer by concentrating risk with one payer rather than each company paying is ridiculous - the bankruptcies might be separated by centuries rather than decades, but the effects are so much worse that it's difficult to even compare the two with a straight face. One notes that this doesn't happen to nearly the same degree with small corporations; why would making the pool larger make us all better off?
The second piece of evidence comes from Gladwell's open offering of, yet complete ignorance of the other, better answer:
When Bethlehem Steel filed for bankruptcy, it owed about four billion dollars to its pension plan, and had another three billion dollars in unmet health-care obligations. Two years later, in 2003, the pension fund was terminated and handed over to the federal government's Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. The assets of the company—Sparrows Point and a handful of other steel mills in the Midwest—were sold to the New York-based investor Wilbur Ross.
Ross acted quickly. He set up a small trust fund to help defray Bethlehem's unmet retiree health-care costs, cut a deal with the union to streamline work rules, put in place a new 401(k) savings plan—and then started over. The new Bethlehem Steel had a dependency ratio of 0 to 1. Within about six months, it was profitable.
So the answer here was not spreading the risk among companies, per se - although that was the effect, since workers basically diversified the risk of Bethelem Steel going bankrupt by buying stocks and bonds in a wide range of companies and governments. It was the opposite - mass-individualization. The key is to put workers in control of their own retirement and health care costs through individual accounts. The company now gives them cold, hard cash (with strings attached to be sure, but it's still their's) instead of IOUs. They share profits during good times. They take it with them when they leave, and when the company goes bankrupt. Sounds pretty socialist to me.
The New Autopreneurs
5.21.2009
Meet the New Boss (5)
Beyond the rhetoric, then, Obama has told the world that America's definitions of terror remain its own. He says it's not a reversal? It is. The president has reminded the world of a Cheney-ism: We know terrorism when we see it, and when we see it, we'll let you know.
Bill of Federalism is here!
5.19.2009
Anti-counterfeit (for now) tech in color printers...
I knew someone would get around to saying this...
But, I thought it was greedy bankers and lack of regulation that caused this (just kidding, I didn't really think that).
To sum it up, Geithner confessed that worldwide monetary policy was too loose too long creating a huge bubble in asset prices. Basically, there was too much money chasing investments. Like flood waters, money seeks ever higher returns, pushing prices of real estate and commodities at rates exceeding 15% annually in 2004 and 2005.
5.17.2009
Economics 000
I'd love to show this to some 12 year old Indian kid whose choices in life are between farming a barely-farmable half-acre in hopes of feeding his family at the whims of the rain, and dying at the ripe old age of 44, versus working in a factory in Madras for the evil corporate machine. I'm sure he would go for the "sustainable" option.
5.16.2009
Shit hitting fan somewhat earlier than expected
The U.S. Treasury auction of long-term bonds on Thursday was “terrible”, in the words of one Wall Street economist, with the rate on the 30 year bond jumping from 4.1 to 4.3 percent. This is just the first sign that the debt-based Obama economic stimulus plan is about to become a major drag on the recovery, just as expected.
5.09.2009
Hydrogen schmydrogen
In terms of energy density, storage, and safety, hydrocarbons are the best thing around, at least chemically speaking. If and when it becomes reasonable to have renewable transportation fuel manufactured from primary energy, it will come in one of two forms: hydrocarbons derived from cash crops (ethanol, biodiesel), or hydrocarbon synfuels manufactured from water and atmospheric CO2. Hydrogen is a non-starter. I did my 6th grade science fair project on the hydrogen economy and predicted we'd all be taking 2 hour trips to Tokyo by now. I drank the Koolaid. But if you do the numbers, it just doesn't work out. Read Zubrin's article, it really lays the whole idea to waste beautifully.
4.21.2009
Blog Challenge Verdict: Free Darko
Consumer confidence: not such an easy knob to turn?
Most of us sense that there’s more to revival than sudden desires for phones or cars, that the consumer isn’t always a mindless mall rat. Rational caution may be beneficial, tax breaks aimed at stimulating consumption, perverse.
Still, the same Chicago trust-o-meter carries some negative messages. In December the pollsters asked: “Have the government interventions in financial markets over the last three months made you more or less confident in investment in the stock market?”
A full 80 percent replied “less,” an annihilating mark for the performance ofGeorge W. Bush, then-Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson and Fed ChairmanBen Bernanke. Asked a similar question last month, 67 percent replied “less confident.”