4.20.2009

Blog Challenge Verdict: Planet Money

Planet money will become one of my frequented blogs I think.  Thanks to Simon for throwing me that bone.  I wrote more about PM in this post and this post.  To summarize,  the blog brings outstanding data to light,  but it tends not to ask the obvious questions or make the obvious connections.  The good part of this is that it stays relatively apolitical - although of course different posters have their own mild bias.  If one contends that Americans are reasonably rational creatures (I would contend this), then the readers can draw their own conclusions.  And the blog does have comments, which of course has lots of punches and conclusions.

4.17.2009

Blog Challenge Verdict: Huffington Post

I think I'm starting to catch on to the M.O. of the Huff Post after about 10 days of reading it.  There is no M.O.  Some articles are actually well-researched, some are just absolute opinion-backed crap with few to no facts.  It's the ultimate wheat and chaff bonanza.  I'm not sure if it is the former or latter that pays the bills, but for my money and time they could use a good editor to cut the volume in half and throw out the prodigious amount of editorial filler they publish.  For instance, Arianna herself posted this today on the front page: 

It's what people do when the only two ideas they have -- tax cuts and deregulation -- have been given full expression for the last 8 years and failed. Miserably.
That was the end of the point, in a 30-paragraph article.  That was assertion, argument, and conclusion #1.  It was followed by a 8-10 more un-backed, completely unassociated paragraph rants about Republicans, tea parties, socialism and fascism, and so on.  The post ends with a video that shows a bunch of white supremacists Heil Hitlering.  The other side's issues are twisted, the most radical statements are taken as typical, and perhaps worst of all, all the points are countered by burning down strawmen.  Reading those posts, one wonders if they should call it the Ad Hominem Post.  I just made that up right now.

On the other hand, there is this well-thought and well-argued article about fiscal problems caused by knee-jerk anti-deflationism.  Essentially, the Fed has now traded its formerly solid treasury assets for the worst of the toxic securities, and has basically lost control of its ability to re-shrink the money supply after the liquidity takes hold; it also lacks the political will to do so and the sheer chutzpah to crush the government and consumers under high interest rates.  The likely result will be large rate spreads and high inflation, since printing money is the only way to pay off debts you can't finance as interest rates rise.

The blog seems to fixate on certain things and churn out a bunch of poli-fluff, but at the same time it refutes its own hubris by attracting good writers who, for lack of a better theory, must sneak their press in under the radar.  It reads like a college newspaper: there's the one or two golden truth articles that the editor in chief worked her tail off for 3 years to get the freedom to write.  And then there's the filler.  It's a frustrating blog to visit.  You know you're going to get some very good writing, but you also know you're going to have to wade through sludge to find it.  

4.16.2009

Meet the new boss (#4)

Another day, another "Dude - where's my country?"

The American President's call "to free the world of the menace of a nuclear nightmare" was hot air, Mr Sarkozy's diplomatic staff told him in a report. "It was rhetoric – not a speech on American security policy but an export model aimed at improving the image of the United States," they said. Most of Mr Obama's proposals had already been made by the Bush administration and Washington was dragging its feet on disarmament and treaties against nuclear proliferation, the leaked report said.

4.15.2009

Bad government vs. good government, or... we have always been at war with Eastasia

It's amazing how the power vs. outrage tug of war has swung. Maybe you believe Bush's actions can be justified while Obama's cannot. And by most accounts Caesar was a good emperor and Caligula was not. But Caligula never would have become emperor if Caesar hadn't accepted the title first.

The outcry du jour (linked from Transterrestrial Musings) is about an obviously highly politically-motivated DHS report about domestic radical groups. The phraseology appears to be highly motivated by what you might see if you put a guy named Hannity and a guy name Colmes, or two angry monkeys, in a room:
(U) Leftwing extremism in the United States can be broadly divided into those groups, movements, and adherents that are primarily hate-oriented (based on hatred of particular economic classes, and religious groups, particularly Christianity), and those that are mainly pro-government, preferring federal authority and particularly federal judicial rulings over state or local authority. It may include groups and individuals that are dedicated to a single issue, such as opposition to restrictions on abortion, immigration, or gay marriage.
Everyone is currently getting burned by Democrats. Unfortunately, many of the tools they are usuing were institutions that Republicans either created, consolidated, or pioneered as a tool. Dems finally caught on to the political carte blanche of massive deficit spending. The DHS has turned into - gasp! - NKVD lite. Bush's irresponsible bailouts make Obama's even more irresponsible bailouts defensible.

4.13.2009

A truer description of the state...

From the comments on http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2009/04/some_libertaria.html

Almost perfect, but he fails to mention how the reps give a quarter the money to their friends, then the McDonalds manager comes after the whole group with a shotgun because they stiffed him.
Say we're on a bus trip with 100 people and stop to have dinner at a mall. 90 people have money to buy dinner, but 10 people forgot their wallets.

First, we decide everyone needs food, so we're going to pool our resources, since we can spread the cost. Then someone mentions that we could negotiate a deal with one of the vendors if we all buy the same meal. Lots of people grumble but a chorus of "ok" sounds like a majority so the "group" decides to do it.

Everyone breaks up into cliques and elects a representative. Then the representatives decide what we'll have for dinner, and how much everyone should pay ($8 each to cover the 10 who can't pay). Then the vendors hear what we're doing and start lobbying. The Chinese food stall offers $50 to a representative if he changes his vote. The pizza place offers to throw in free cookies if they are chosen. Finally, we find out that we're all having Filet o Fish value meals, with Diet Coke and fries.

When the reps go to pay, they realize they don't have enough money. More than 10 people didn't pay, or someone pocketed some money. It changed hands about 3 or 4 times. They have to order some cheaper food to get enough.

Everyone lines up to get their food, but at the end, there are 7 people in line and the food has run out. The 7 have to buy their own meal, but one of them is a person who forgot their wallet. A friend pays for his meal.

The guy who paid for three meals is really pissed off, and he uses the f-word about 10 times a minute for the entire bus ride home when talking to his friend. He also makes loud comments about the manhood of one representative and threatens to beat up another. The seven people who didn't get food are angry. Several people hated the fish and just ate fries. Some gave their sandwich to others, but a few just threw them out. That pissed off two fat people who were still hungry later on the bus and a couple other people on general principle, who lectured the others. When we got back home, most people asked, who is the moron who came up with that idea?

Making sense of health care (r)

I've come to realize that, until we have healthy eternal life, nobody will be happy with their health care system.  That said, there are certain things that make health care a really tough thing to diagnose and repair.  For instance, in most human endeavors when people say "oh, but times have changed," one can say with fair certainty that they are full of shit.  As Baz Lurhmann said, "Prices will rise, politicians will philander, and you too will grow old.  And when you do, you will fantasize that when you were young, prices were reasonable, politicians were noble, and children respected their elders."

It's said often by both sides, for instance, that much of the problems we are having currently with Social Security are the result of health care.  Well, it's not said that way, but it's what people mean when they say the retirement age should be raised.   And that's not the whole of it - 40 years ago, you died of cancer or a heart attack, and quickly.  Now, you probably get cured once or twice, at the cost of 2-3 years productive employment.  My Pepere had open heart surgery back in '84 - he's still going strong today.  These days, you can almost bank on a few rounds of chemo, open heart surgery, 30 years of insulin shots, or a hip replacement before whatever really takes you out takes you out.  People don't save up for retirement anymore so much as convalescence.  

Make no mistake - this is progress.  However, our lives are backloaded with costs nowadays - those 20 bonus years cost a lot more than any other 20 years, and while we're paying half our incomes in taxes and burning ourselves out to keep and extra thousand sq ft. of roof over our heads, we aren't saving for the personal apocalypse.  But who would deny those 20 years to anyone?

I've heard horror stories from countries with socialized health care, and from countries with relatively open health care.  I've seen surveys that say the US has the best health care in the western world, and surveys that say the US has the worst health care in the western world.  I've talked to people from all over, and like I said, nobody likes their health care system all that much.  

This thread will try to come to some answer I can be happy with about health care.  And yes, I'm starting off biased, because I can't see how politicians and bureacrats can make better decisions for my health than I can.  But I'll try to keep an open mind, because like I said; this is a very unusual territory.  In my first 1/3 of life I have done very little to  support myself over my last 1/3 of life.  I am currently one of the uninsured millions (that link, by the way, goes to a former Bush economic staffer and includes lots of mailing list emails from inside the White House... interesting reading).  I don't think I can trust Medicare and Social Security to be there when I need it 30+ years from now.  So it's ideological, but it's also personal.

Today's entry:  primary care.  The primary care "dream" is one of house visits by doctors you call by first name.  More substantively, it is one of preventive medicine, early detection, consistent and quality care for chronic conditions, and reasonable prices and service for common ailments.  Movies and Ron Paul lead us to believe that this was commonplace in the US at least prior to the 1960s or so.  Medicine has changed a lot since then, and most ailments are not most effectively cured by whatever fits in a lunch pail.  But how many times have you waited for an hour at a megaclinic only to be told that it was nothing serious and slapped with a prescriptions that should have been easy to get over the phone?  I can count the number of times that I actually needed to be in a doctor's office in the last ten years on one hand.  To a large extent, a handful of assholes screwed it up for the rest of us with irresponsible malpractice suits, and the courts didn't help with vomit-inducing rewards.  Another big factor appears to be the guilding of the medical profession, which has priced MD degrees plum out of the primary care market.  Finally, the separation from the consumer that mandated employer healthcare has brought about has made the whole process much more bureacratic for both sides... in the end, lawyers always trump doctors.

I lived in the Netherlands, where health care is run by huge government-corporate cartels.  It is a utility model, and seems to work okay for basic care.  You are legally required to buy insurance from a list of approved corporations.  According to my Dutch friends, those companies often try to get out of paying the bill, but I'm not sure if that is an exceptional thing or the norm, much as I'm not sure which is the case in the US.  I went to a clinic there for a tetanus shot, and it was pretty similar to my clinic experiences in America: 2 hour wait for a 5 minute consult, and 80 euro minimum charge.  Not terribly unreasonable considering tetanus would have killed me slowly and painfully 100 years ago - but then again, I was paying cash.  My wife-to-be claims that Britain's health care system is awesome; but she hasn't really lived in Britain as an adult so - she knows better than me, but her depth of experience is limited.

But what about socialized healthcare in America?  How does that work?  By all accounts, Medicaid has its problems, but it's hard to expect much from a program that caters to a relatively small, and unvocal voting bloc... yes, socialized healthcare will disproportionately screw over the poor too, probably even more than our current ER and patchwork program does (unless a lot more of us are poor, but I digress).  Medicare, from personal anecdotes, is a ton of paperwork and never pays for everything you need; but it does help quite a bit.  The VA, however, is underfunded and should be a national embarrassment, except Americans really don't seem to give a shit about their soldiers after all.  

One has to expect that a socialized system would be similar to all three in terms of primary and emergency care (I'm not getting into other aspects today, like the impact on innovation).  Since it would serve all but the richest among us (who would pay for better doctors and no waits), it would have to be responsive - at least to some groups.  The groups that vote disproportionately, like seniors, would probably benefit at the cost of others.  The companies that got in bed with the government and performed well on whatever blunt-instrument statistics the bureaucrats were paying attention to that year would make like bandits.  

Another model might be public education.  The poor would get screwed, similarly to how they get screwed by our current education system.  People would probably be required to go to the nearest hospital regardless of quality, or else spend extra for private care.  Doctors and nurses would have to defer to bureaucrats like teachers must defer to curricula, but that's not terribly different than what is happening today with HMOs and PPOs and the rest of the alphabet soup.  By all accounts of socialized systems, waits for treatments, surgeries, consults, and everything else would go to insane levels - not a problem, unless you have a degenerative or debilitating illness.

Overall, we've been pretty well primed for crappy primary care in this country from 40 years of partially-socialized healthcare already.  There is some choice of company, but the regulations and judicial record have forced the hand of most health insurers and providers so that the product is uniformly meh all around.  So, going from 5 or 6 huge politically-driven corporations to 1 huge politically-controlled agency probably won't be a devastating jump, but it won't fix people's primary-care complaints either.  So it's pretty much a wash.  I think, if people had the choice, they would prefer to keep primary care private - it's still the most affordable part of the system, and it's an elastic good in that people can choose to skip this year's physical or flu shot.

Then again, as Baz says, "The real troubles in your life are apt to be things that never crossed your worried mind.  The kind that blindsides you at 4 pm on some idle Tuesday."  The whole thing gets more complicated when you introduce Really Bad Things.  That's next time: catastrophic care.  Or will it be medical innovation?  Wait and see.

Meet the new boss... (#3)

http://legalinsurrection.blogspot.com/2009/04/youve-been-punked-by-obama-detainee.html

Now comes "The Detainee Episode." No, not Brooks again. He learned his lesson. Liberal bloggers and columnists who are wringing their hands dry over Obama's continuation of George Bush's policies with regard to enemy combatants (now "detainee who lent substantial support to al-Qaeda") and other aspects of the war on terror (now "overseas contingency operation") such as electronic eavesdropping. 

This is too easy.  In a sad, soul-sucking, faith-destroying way.

4.12.2009

...And YOU'RE Owin' and Payin'

http://www.owenandpayne.com/why_you_owe.php

Funny stuff.  "Picking up the girls at accounting school" ... right.

Meet the new boss... (#2)

http://drugwartreason.blogspot.com/2009/04/obama-plans-intensified-pot-arrests.html

Now, with yet another slap in the face of social justice advocates, who had been led to believe that Obama's campaign of change would mean something other than escalation and militarization of the same old drug war, the administration promises more marijuana possession arrests at the federal level.
You can't make this stuff up!

Meet the new boss (#1)

http://www.slate.com/id/2215818/

The District Court dismissed the complaint because then-President Bush and Vice President Cheney argued that state secrets would be exposed if the case were litigated. During oral argument before the 9th Circuit, Obama echoed the state-secrets argument made by Bush and Cheney. Similarly, the president who promised "change" is wielding the tool of state secrets in aiming to dismiss, without the gathering of evidence, challenges to the National Security Agency's Terrorist Surveillance Program, which entailed warrantless phone or e-mail interceptions of American citizens on American soil in contravention of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978.
UPDATE:  Just a word to people who would make me out to be a hater.  I hate.  But note the title of this series of posts.  I hated W, too.  I just want to make sure people who voted for Obama realize that, when they said he was different, they were mistaken.

Lancaster Tea Party; is regulation really the panacea it's made out to be?

Well, I made it to the Lancaster, CA Tea Party this morning at about 11:40 am, just as they started popping balloons.  I went mainly to see what was going on, but since I don't have a car I had to bike the 26 miles - a great workout in any case, on a nice crisp spring desert morning.  Since I got there so late, there wasn't much to do but sign my name to be counted, throw my tea bag in the Washington box, and head to the bus stop.  The event appeared to include a few Republican politicians, which is a bit against the spirit of the Tea Parties, but then again the spirit of the tea parties is pretty broad since it's grass roots.  I would love to get out of Mojave on Wednesday and head down to the real LA county.

On another topic, I keep hearing about how regulation is the end all response to this.  Whether or not you think the current rules for financial institutions are too lax, do you really think that bringing in government regulators will help?  Or will congresspeople be bribed into creating loopholes for their friends and benefactors?  Will bureaucracy keep track of everyone on a level playing field?  Or will it only slow down the rule-followers while the rule breakers launder their money and find new financial instruments that operate outside the rules cough! mortgage backed securities!  

Revisiting Planet Money

I'm really starting to like this blog.  I stand behind what I said yesterday - they pull too many punches.  But, in doing so they manage to get really shocking stories out.  If they went after every piece of drudge they dug up, they would be instantly painted as fiercely partisan by both sides.

I'm talking today about a graph I pointed to yesterday.  It is a "picture worth a thousand words," truly.  File this under "things not to do during a credit crisis, exhibit A:" prey off investors fear and suck up all the credit.

Also file under "fighting the last war."  I just read Amity Shlaes' excellent book about the Great Depression, The Forgotten Man.  The Depression was brought on by a number of things, but the real disaster at the beginning was deflation, brought on by the stock market crash of 1929 and the closing of foreign markets due to Smoot-Hawley, as well as the all-too-familiar "Fed getting called out after keeping interest rates too low for too long."  The New Deal was either a godsend in tough times that went on too long, or else a disaster that prolonged a sharp downturn into a decade-long depression, depending whom you talk to.  But, whatever else you say about Roosevelt, he at least forced himself to balance the budget from time to time.  Roosevelt did this through a series of arbitrary taxes on rich, corporations, and consumables.  The effect may not have been so bad if the structure had stabilized at some point.

What the early Great Depression did not have was a credit crisis - in fact, gold was pouring into the country from Europe in 1929 after the crash, and if Hoover hadn't stepped in the money supply would have probably inflated and we could have avoided the deflation problem and probably the whole Depression.  Unfortunately, the current depression does include a credit crisis.  Really, I think the danger of deflation has been grossly overstated - the housing market is still above historical trends, and the stock market is a poor indicator of short-term money supply.  The problem is liquidity, brought on by too much credit being locked in unmovable assets.  The market solution would be to re-balance these - banks and lenders who have low-risk portfolios would essentially feed off the carcasses of high-risk institutions in a buyer's market.  To balance portfolios, they would use a similar amount of cash to buy up low-risk debt in the form of corporate and municipal bonds in order to balance their portfolios.  This would fund capital and infrastructure improvements, making construction jobs available, decrease layoffs, etc.  

The problem is illustrated by Planet Money's chart.  The federal government has flooded the low-risk debt market.  That money is no longer available for corporations and local governments to buy at low interest rates.  In the middle of a credit crisis, the federal government is sucking up all the credit!  They're fighting the current depression with Great Depression tools, completely ignoring this fatal flaw.

4.11.2009

COP report that will be ignored by treasury...

Or, why conspiracy theorists are nuts.  This is a part of the government trying to be rational and responsible, and getting ignored in the process:

“Allowing institutions to fail in a structured manner supervised by appropriate regulators offers a clearer exit strategy than allowing those institutions to drift into government control piecemeal,” the report said."
This is from a congressional oversight panel for the TARP bailout.  

Why rich people are good for the economy... even filthy rich people

One thing that annoys me about the current tax debate is, of course, people like Joe Biden who shout admonishments like "It's time to be patriotic."  I think most people can see past the us vs. them bullshit on that one, at least eventually.  I mean, it just has too much of a Nazi ring to it I hope.  You might not think it's fair that people are paid a lot more than others; but throwing around words like "patriotic" just seems so... Dick Cheney.

That is not what annoys me most though.  It's the complete unwillingness or inability of most commentators, and the rich themselves, to stand up for themselves.  The replies are always on the defensive... like the current Economist debate about highly "progressive" tax rates.  The argument is mainly founded on assumptions about effects of high taxes on productivity, but the antagonist, Cato's Chris Edwards finally flesh-wounds a point almost by accident:
It still makes no sense to impose high taxes on them because those entrepreneurs are more likely to use the cash productively than the government. Indeed, from the beginning of Silicon Valley, wave after wave of millionaires have funded the next wave of business successes through angel financing and venture capital. Obviously, that would not have been possible under Piketty's 80% tax rate.
It's an expanding pie, which Edwards says repeatedly.  But who expands the pie?  Many people would like to think government does, and there is some evidence that infrastructure is a net good.  But looking at the proportion of medical advances and high-tech companies that come out of countries with relatively stable and liberal (that's classically liberal, sorry) governments one has to ask: who expands the pie rapidly and efficiently?  A comment on the sidebar:

Picketty [the tax proponent] tends to ignore the hardly theoretical expanding pie, like the expanding universe, which is accomplished only by these driven, high-earning individuals who, through no altruistic intent, do not get enough credit for their socio-economic contributions. 

It's people with lots of extra cash, and I would argue quite vehemently that, since these people are also the greatest charity-givers and philantropists, it is not all with lack of altruism.  A friend of mine who should know better dropped some comment about how the rich hoard all the money, like a) it's some fixed-size thing and b) they're stuffing it in a mattress.  Rich money goes into stocks and other investments, which directly leads to employment.  Hence the high unemployment in places like New Deal America, where the rich were taxed at extremely high rates near 80%; and modern-day Europe, with similar levies.  As a "poor" employee of a start up that is financed by millionaires, I see this every payday.  Rich buy things, things that the middle class makes.  Ask any small businessman, and he will tell you he aims to get rich clients.  Rich clients are early adopters and luxury buyers, so they fund the development of mass-market goods.  

People balk at all this money going through the rich man's hands, but not at many times that amount going through a politician's hands.  The argument is also made by a lot of pro-government people that it should be channeled for the good of society.  But nobody really knows what that is, and I trust a million investors and philantropists to address problems efficiently much more than I trust bureaucrats and politicians... if only because the investors and philantropists are spending their own money.  The rich are not black holes where wealth goes to die; indeed quite the opposite.  They are by and large where wealth goes to make babies.     

The rich need to re-cast themselves as great redistributors of wealth.  Get the focus off how they deserve their money or how they earned their money - even a stout libertarian like myself knows that much of it is a product of luck.  Get the focus on the people that money flows to - the charities, the churches, the small businessmen, the zero-interest tuition loan, the blue-collar job saved by the investor with the wherewithal to buy low in a recession.  Above a certain point, it stops being personal wealth and becomes something much bigger and more inclusive... after all,  most rich people are well aware they can't take it with them.  That point is made by a commenter whose conclusion I disagree with:
Dear Sir, If you were to decide for ANY system, rich ,poor tax, social giving, war machine, what each of us have to ask, if I put X dollars into it, what will be the end product. If the STATS ,shows that one group gain with no limits, then it is wrong. if however, it balance itself i.e for example if the poor have enough to eat, send their kid to a good school, be able to see a doctor when they are sick,without losing the roof over their headhave a roof over their heads, the rich can have ALL THE GOLD ThEY WANT ,they can eat it, sleep in it and die in it, however since this not the case, we need to tax the rich.
There is certainly a level beyond which a "poor" person has no right to complain.  This commenter, like most of what I call the 80/20ers, employs a moving scale for which nothing will ever be good enough as a floor.  For instance, show a poor Briton to a middle-class Angolan and I guarantee who will switch places with whom (a great thing about immigrants... again, another post).  And I can understand that, as a society gets richer, it is moral to move the floor up as well... just because American bums live like Haitian kings, doesn't mean it's a good life.  But the poster makes the usual 80/20 failure of imagination by implying that it is the government that must do this.

In fact, government is quite bad at getting people out of poverty; especially when compared with accountable charities and, um, corporations that offer jobs for unskilled labor.  That's a topic for another post.  It is the rich who fund charities at by far the highest rates, except when you tax them for doing so.  It should be no surprise that they are not all or even mostly evil people.  

Taking the blog challenge

Alarmed by the samed-ness of the blogs I've been frequenting lately, I threw down the gauntlet on some of friends to switch blogs for a week.  I gave three of my long term favorites, which I have frequented for a couple years at least:

Reason's Hit & Run - multimedia-intensive, well argued, not belligerent
Cosmic Log - Good site for pop science updates
Reiss's Pieces - My model for a great sports team blog

Since my long-term favorites don't exactly reflect the now, and I usually have some standbys for what seems like no other reason than getting really angry at my government and fellow citizens, I also threw in Instapundit.  

In return, I got:

ichoosetofightwhiskey (his personal blog, mainly marathon training)

Free Darko is a basketball strategy blog.  Entertaining, but a little too eggheady for me.  I prefer the more dumb and absurd Truehoop and Ball Don't Lie.

First impressions of each:  Huff Post reminded me of Instapundit.  Lots of mudslinging, which is their foremost similarity - if you just took out the articles and posts based on poorly substantiated attacks on the other side from either of these blogs you would not have much left.  The articles that did actually argue a point did so with tired arguments that only sometimes fit the case and then only by coincidence; again very similar to Instapundit.  There was some substance in some articles, but I have to conclude that this blog is mainly useful for inciting righteous fury.  Has anybody coined the term "soap-blopera" yet?  If not, I just did.

Planet money was another thorn in my side, this one much stickier.  Because it is a pretty darn good blog.  For some reason NPR is the best thing on radio and also one of the best news portals on the internet.   Unfortunately, while it does look for new and slightly deeper angles, the reports are typical NPR neuter - I wish they would combine some of their thoroughness in chasing a story with skepticism in questioning the people they find to give it to them... for instance, a recent story asks the question "do banks need the FDIC?" and then goes straight to an FDIC pr person for the answer.  Duh.  On the other hand, it asks questions like "What is the new normal?" and post charts that show (my interpretation) the federal government sucking up all the credit in a credit crisis.  In other words, good questions, but too timid with the answers in some cases.

As an example, here's a quote from Robert Reich in one of the posts:

This is still not the Great Depression of the 1930s, but it is a Depression. And the only way out is government spending on a very large scale. We should stop worrying about Wall Street. Worry about American workers. Use money to build up Main Street, and the future capacities of our workforce.
It would be nice to get a counterpoint, or at least some critical questions.  Like, why didn't massive government spending work in the New Deal to lower unemployment?  Or, how will you give main street jobs without investment ("Wall Street")?